Compensation for co-op students a hot topic in Greenville Auto Tech Advisory Council meeting


GREENVILLE – The pay scale for students working co-ops and how to incentivize students to pursue careers in automotive technology dominated the conversation during Greenville High School’s first Auto Tech Advisory Council meeting of the 2018-19 school year.

Greenville’s Auto Tech Advisory Council – comprised of Greenville High School staff, Sinclair Community College automotive technology staff, local mechanics and a GHS student – met Tuesday morning to provide guidance for the school’s auto tech program. The council is crucial to the success of the program, said instructor Travis Nicholas, who led Tuesday’s meeting with fellow instructor Matt Obringer.

“The Advisory Council is really what makes our program where it is,” Nicholas said. “A lot of advisory councils, committees aren’t as well organized as ours. All the people that are involved are people that hire our students so they know what they want them to learn; they know what we need to teach them to be successful in their business. So that’s kind of how we guide our program.”

Greenville’s auto technology program is open to high school juniors and seniors. Along with teaching students in the classroom, the program helps connect dealerships and other mechanic shops with students who can learn through on-the-job experience. Seniors who prove themselves as being worthy have the opportunity to co-op, spending part of the school day working and earning money.

“That’s the carrot,” Nicholas said. “That’s what they strive for. If you can make money when you’re supposed to be at school, that’s a big deal. That’s what I did, that’s what Mr. Obringer did, and it’s something that’s really worked out well for this program and other CT classes, too.”

Members of the council expressed concerns about the pay scale for those student employees and how to best motivate them. A lot of students today think they shouldn’t have to start at the bottom – both financially and in job responsibilities, council members said.

One business owner conveyed a story of firing a student who wasn’t happy with his first paycheck, Nicholas talked about a student who took a factory job where he was given more money only to find he didn’t enjoy that job, and council members expressed concerns about losing students to jobs at fast-food restaurants where thy possibly could work more hours and earn more money.

While wanting to satisfy the needs of student employees, business owners said extra money already is spent on training them and fixing their mistakes. Plus, some council members said education is part of the value of co-ops and at least the students are making some money instead of making nothing in the classroom.

Director of Career Technology & Special Education Andrea Townsend said businesses could offer incremental pay raises to appeal to students, comparing them to leveling up in a video game.

Council members also suggested giving away tools as rewards, which add value and could incentivize students to remain in the automotive field.

Greenville High School Principal Stan Hughes said even consistent and frequent feedback, which requires no monetary commitment, could appeal to today’s youth.

The council didn’t want to set standard rules for pay raises or other incentives, recognizing each business has its own operating methods, but agreed clearly defined expectations and timelines for pay raises could be strong motivators for students.

“You could see in the meeting they’re very passionate,” Nicholas said. “It went way long just because they have passion for the topics, and I knew that, and I put them in that situation because they bring it all out so they can definitely help guide us and to make the program where it’s at today and to help the success of our students.”

For the dealerships and mechanic shops, finding ways to attract and retain employees is a concern as more and more Americans near the retirement age.

“Like one of the guys talked earlier, the Baby Boomer era, you know, they’re getting ready to retire so every field in America is going to be just busting over so there’s going to be a big need not just in automotive technology but everywhere,” Nicholas said.

Nicholas is encouraged by the level of interest Greenville is seeing in automotive technology as the foundation classes for freshmen and sophomores have increased in popularity the past couple years.

“There is a lot of interest, more than we thought there would be,” he said. “We have an overflow in the classes, which is a good thing.”

Ultimately, the Advisory Council’s goal is to develop passions and prepare students for careers in the automotive field.

“If you’re working with your hands, you like automotive, I think this business you can go really far,” Nicholas said. “You can make a lot of money, especially if you get around and in the bigger cities and things like that. So that’s what we’re trying to do. We’re trying to keep them in our industry, and that’s the whole goal.”

Greenville High School’s Auto Tech Advisory Council devoted much of Tuesday’s meeting to discussing compensation for students working in co-ops. High School’s Auto Tech Advisory Council devoted much of Tuesday’s meeting to discussing compensation for students working in co-ops. Kyle Shaner | The Daily Advocate

By Kyle Shaner

[email protected]

Kyle Shaner may be reached at 937-569-4316. Follow me on Twitter @KShanerAdvocate or get updates on Facebook by searching Darke County Sports or Advocate 360. For more features online go to

No posts to display