Best to face OSU football team


When the Big Ten Network announced its All-Decade team last week it reminded me how many great players I have seen play against Ohio State in writing about OSU football since 1992.

So, I decided to make a list of the best players I’ve seen at each position based on how they played when they competed against Ohio State and on their overall careers. Call it my All-Opponents All-Three Decades Team.

The No. 1 requirement was that they had to have been a starter in a game against Ohio State, which eliminated great players like Pat Fitzgerald and Dallas Clark. No. 2 was that I had to have been in the press box when they played against OSU.

Here’s my list:


1. Drew Brees (Purdue). 2. Vince Young (Texas). 3. Deshaun Watson (Clemson). 4. Philip Rivers (North Carolina State). 5. Peyton Manning (Tennessee).

Honorable mention: Russell Wilson (Wisconsin), Baker Mayfield (Oklahoma), Tom Brady (Michigan), Antwaan Randle El (Indiana), Colt McCoy (Texas), Denard Robinson (Michigan), Tajh Boyd (Clemson), Connor Cook (Michigan State), Trevor Lawrence (Clemson).

Brees is the Big Ten career leader in passing yards with 11,792. He and his coach Joe Tiller might not have revolutionized Big Ten offenses but they certainly changed them. Only three of the top 25 quarterbacks in passing yards in Big Ten history played before Brees. His signature moment against Ohio State was passing for 455 yards and three touchdown in 2000 to help Purdue get to the Rose Bowl for the first time in 34 years.

For some people, Young’s struggles in the NFL have obscured how great he was in his final college season when he led Texas to the national championship in 2005. In a 25-22 win over OSU he threw the game-winning touchdown pass with 2 1/2 minutes to play, passed for 270 yards and two TDs and rushed for 76 yards.

Watson passed for 259 yards and a touchdown and rushed for 57 yards and two TDs in Clemson’s 31-0 win over Ohio State in a College Football Playoff semifinal in 2016. Rivers passed for 315 yards and four touchdowns when the Buckeyes held on for a 44-38 triple-overtime win against North Carolina State in 2003.

Manning completed 20 of 35 passes for 182 yards and a touchdown in a 20-14 win by Tennessee over Ohio State in the Citrus Bowl at the end of the 1995 season. It rained for 12 straight hours before the game and the field was a mess. It wasn’t Manning’s passing numbers that made him one of my most memorable quarterbacks. It was that his demeanor was more like what you’d expect from a guy in his third or fourth year in the NFL, not a college sophomore.


1. Ron Dayne (Wisconsin). 2. Saquon Barkley (Penn State). 3. Tshimanga Biakabutuka (Michigan). 4. Ki-Jana Carter (Penn State). 5. Curtis Enis (Penn State).

Honorable mention: Derrick Henry (Alabama), Curtis Martin (Pittsburgh), Tyrone Wheatley (Michigan), Laurence Maroney (Minnesota), Napoleon Kaufman (Washington), Garrison Hearst (Georgia), Larry Johnson (Penn State), Melvin Gordon (Wisconsin), Mike Alstott (Purdue), Chris Perry (Michigan), Tevin Coleman (Indiana), Mike Hart (Michigan).

Dayne, a 250-pound tailback, might not fit into some 21st century offenses. He might not have been everybody’s idea of a 1990s tailback. But he was a perfect fit in Wisconsin’s offense from 1996-1999. His 7,125 yards rushing is still an NCAA record. He rushed for 161 yards and four touchdowns in a 42-17 win over Ohio State in 1999 and gained 72 yards in 1996.

Barkley combined power and speed. He rushed for more than 1,000 yards three times from 2015-2017, caught 54 passes his final season at Penn State and returned two kickoffs for touchdowns, including one for 97 yards against Ohio State. His best game against OSU was in 2015 when he rushed for 194 yards.

Biakabutuka’s 313 yards rushing on 37 carries in Michigan’s 31-23 win over Ohio State in 1995 still creates nightmares for Buckeyes fans. No running back has ever run for more yards in a game against OSU.

He was hardly a one-hit wonder, rushing for 1,724 yards that season. But it was his only big game against OSU. Until that day his career totals against Ohio State were four carries for 15 yards.

Carter, who went to high school at Westerville South, rushed for more than 1,000 yards in his two seasons as Penn State’s No. 1 running back in 1993 and 1994 before the Cincinnati Bengals made him the No. 1 overall pick in the 1995 NFL draft. He ran for 123 yards against OSU in 1993 and 137 yards in 1994.

Enos, from Mississinawa Valley, ran for more than 1,000 yards his last two years at Penn State in 1996 and 1997. He rushed for 146 yards against OSU in 1995 and 211 yards in 1997.

Mississinawa Valley graduate, Penn State and Chicago Bears running back, Curtis Enos talks to 2012 Bradford football team after returning to Darke County to coach the Railroaders for several seasons. Valley graduate, Penn State and Chicago Bears running back, Curtis Enos talks to 2012 Bradford football team after returning to Darke County to coach the Railroaders for several seasons. Gaylen Blosser |
Who are the best football players Ohio State has faced in the last three decades?

By Jim Naveau

Lima Daily News

No posts to display